0Joe Morgenstern
3.65Joe Morgenstern’s “Surface of Sin” Gets Stuck on One Note 
| Quality of Writing | Quality of Argument |
| Spoiler Avoidance | Presentation |
Word Count: 417 |
|
3.53Joe Morgenstern Writes a Review on the Way to Dinner in “The Desolation”
| Quality of Writing | Quality of Argument |
| Spoiler Avoidance | Presentation |
Word Count: 295 |
|
3.5Joe Morgenstern’s “The Furnace” Is Dressed-Up Prose Looking for Way Home
| Quality of Writing | Quality of Argument |
| Spoiler Avoidance | Presentation |
Word Count: 466 |
|
3.78Joe Morgenstern’s “Catching Fire: . .” Finds Its Mark
| Quality of Writing | Quality of Argument |
| Spoiler Avoidance | Presentation |
Word Count: 700 |
|
4.15Joe Morgenstern Injects a Little of His Own Agenda Into “Philomena”
| Quality of Writing | Quality of Argument |
| Spoiler Avoidance | Presentation |
Word Count: 432 |
|
3Joe Morgenstern’s “‘Nebraska: State of Grace” Purloins Putative Insight
| Quality of Writing | Quality of Argument |
| Spoiler Avoidance | Presentation |
Word Count: 541 |
|
3.83Joe Mogenstern’s Small but Effective “Thor” Delights
| Quality of Writing | Quality of Argument |
| Spoiler Avoidance | Presentation |
Word Count: 343 |
|
3.3Joe Morgenstern’s “Ender’s Game” Is a Cold Plate of Half-Eaten Critique
| Quality of Writing | Quality of Argument |
| Spoiler Avoidance | Presentation |
Word Count: 345 |
|
4.58Joe Morgenstern’s “McConaughy ‘Club’” Is Moving and Sensitive
| Quality of Writing | Quality of Argument |
| Spoiler Avoidance | Presentation |
Word Count: 565 |
|
3.73Joe Morgenstern’s “Counselor Is a Trial” Is Tight but Confusing
| Quality of Writing | Quality of Argument |
| Spoiler Avoidance | Presentation |
Word Count: 599 |
|
4.6Joe Morgenstern’s Brave “Blue Is the Warmest Color” Pulls No Punches
| Quality of Writing | Quality of Argument |
| Spoiler Avoidance | Presentation |
Word Count: 334 |
|
4.8Joe Morgenstern’s “Unprecedented Force” Shines Throughout
| Quality of Writing | Quality of Argument |
| Spoiler Avoidance | Presentation |
Word Count: 744 |
|
2.05Joe Morgenstern’s “Thrills at Sea, With Some Drift” Is Shallow
| Quality of Writing | Quality of Argument |
| Spoiler Avoidance | Presentation |
Word Count: 853 |
|
3.4Joe Morgenstern’s “Gravity’” Review Is Slackened by Excess Readtime
| Quality of Writing | Quality of Argument |
| Spoiler Avoidance | Presentation |
Word Count: 1546 |
|
3.18Joe Morgenstern’s “‘Rush’: Formula Won” Is a Near Tell-All
| Quality of Writing | Quality of Argument |
| Spoiler Avoidance | Presentation |
Word Count: 709 |
|
2.48Joe Morgenstern’s “Beautifully ’Said’: A Piercing Comedy” Begins Beautifully, but Tapers Off
| Quality of Writing | Quality of Argument |
| Spoiler Avoidance | Presentation |
Word Count: 789 |
|
1.93Joe Morgenstern’s “A Piercing Comedy” Is Painfully Boring
| Quality of Writing | Quality of Argument |
| Spoiler Avoidance | Presentation |
Word Count: 671 |
|
2.33Joe Morgenstern’s “The World’s End” Review Is Like a One-Handed Clap
| Quality of Writing | Quality of Argument |
| Spoiler Avoidance | Presentation |
Word Count: 386 |
|
Critic Averages
| Quality of Writing | Quality of Argument |
| Spoiler Avoidance | Presentation |
Average Word Count: |
|
Review Sampler
Optimus
High Reviews-
Thelma Adams
4.55
Thelma Adams’s “The Book Thief” Is Unabashedly Gleeful -
Margot Harrison 4.35
Margot Harrison Is Delightfully Clinical in “The Counselor” -
Rick Kisonak 4.25
Rick Kisonak’s “Philomena” Is Borderline Vicious but Entertains
