0Scott Nash
3.65Scott Nash’s “The Desolation of Smaug” Is One-Sided and Unclear 
| Quality of Writing | Quality of Argument |
| Spoiler Avoidance | Presentation |
Word Count: 792 |
|
3.08Clunky Prose Extinguishes Scott Nash’s “Catching Fire”
| Quality of Writing | Quality of Argument |
| Spoiler Avoidance | Presentation |
Word Count: 773 |
|
3.75Scott Nash’s “Philomena” Sinks Deeper in Quicksand as It Goes
| Quality of Writing | Quality of Argument |
| Spoiler Avoidance | Presentation |
Word Count: 712 |
|
3.15Scott Nash’s “Nebraska” Is a “What We Learn” Review
| Quality of Writing | Quality of Argument |
| Spoiler Avoidance | Presentation |
Word Count: 1049 |
|
2.15Scott Nash Can’t Find His Footing in “Thor: The Dark World”
| Quality of Writing | Quality of Argument |
| Spoiler Avoidance | Presentation |
Word Count: 376 |
|
3.2Scott and Eric Nash’s “Ender’s Game” Does Just Enough to Graduate
| Quality of Writing | Quality of Argument |
| Spoiler Avoidance | Presentation |
Word Count: 613 |
|
3.73“Review Gravity” by Three Movie Buffs Is Good Times
| Quality of Writing | Quality of Argument |
| Spoiler Avoidance | Presentation |
Word Count: 1102 |
|
2.68Scott Nash Dares to Go Against the Grain in “Rush”
| Quality of Writing | Quality of Argument |
| Spoiler Avoidance | Presentation |
Word Count: 518 |
|
3.68Scott Nash Delivers Accurately and With Brevity in “Don Jon”
| Quality of Writing | Quality of Argument |
| Spoiler Avoidance | Presentation |
Word Count: 418 |
|
2Scott Nash’s “Enough Said” Strikes the Boredom Bell Quickly
| Quality of Writing | Quality of Argument |
| Spoiler Avoidance | Presentation |
Word Count: 499 |
|
2.68Scott Nash’s “The World’s End” Has Fun Moments but Doesn’t End Well
| Quality of Writing | Quality of Argument |
| Spoiler Avoidance | Presentation |
Word Count: 1418 |
|
3.98The Nash Brothers’ “Kick Ass 2” Captivates Readers in Stunning Double Feature
| Quality of Writing | Quality of Argument |
| Spoiler Avoidance | Presentation |
Word Count: 1286 |
|
Critic Averages
| Quality of Writing | Quality of Argument |
| Spoiler Avoidance | Presentation |
Average Word Count: |
|
Review Sampler
Optimus
High Reviews-
Joe Morgenstern
4.58
Joe Morgenstern’s “McConaughy ‘Club’” Is Moving and Sensitive -
Matt Kelemen 4.45
Matt Kelemen’s “Rust-Belt Requiem” Is a Meal You Will Be Eager to Devour -
Genevieve Koski 4.3
Koski’s “A. C. O. D.” Is as Insensitive as It Is Witty and on Target
