Movies  •  Critics  •  About
Existimatum  >  Movies  >  The Best Man Holiday

The Best Man Holiday

ExistiMetric™: 622

When college friends reunite after 15 years over the Christmas holidays, they will discover just how easy it is for long-forgotten rivalries and romances to be ignited.   

80 Rated Reviews

Sort By
Total Score
Sort By
Quality of Writing
Sort By
Quality of Argument
Sort By
Spoiler Avoidance
Sort By
Sort By
Word Count


Top 10 Highly-Rated Reviews


Top 10 Poorly-Rated Reviews


60 Other Reviews
  • James Berardinelli 
    James Berardinelli Refuses to Be Manipulated in “The Best Man Holiday”
  • Kofi Outlaw 
    Kofi Outlaw’s “Best Man Holiday” Stays Upright Despite Some Bumps
  • Kate Erbland 
    Kate Erbland’s “The Best Man Holiday” Freshens Things Up Nicely
  • Ann Hornaday 
    Ann Hornaday’s “Romp and Shameless Tearjerker” Is a Mind Bender
  • Roger Moore 
    Roger Moore’s “The Best Man Holiday” Comes Off as Fair and Sincere
  • Linda Cook 
    Linda Cook’s “Sequel Feels True to Life” Is a Light Holiday Treat
  • Geoff Pevere 
    Geoff Pevere’s “Rich and Beautiful Celebrate Christmas” Is Worth a Chuckle
  • Mark Kermode 
    Mark Kermode Keeps Things Interesting in His Brief “Belated Follow-Up”
  • Mick LaSalle 
    Mick LaSalle’s Thoughtful “‘The Best Man…” Gives Just Enough to Be Good
  • Jeffrey Lyles 
    Jeffrey Lyles Doesn’t Bowl You Over With “The Best Man Holiday”
  • Colin Covert 
    Colin Covert Doesn’t Mince Words in “‘Best Man Holiday”
  • Alonso Duralde 
    Alonso Duralde’s “Yuletide Sequel” Causes a Chuckle Now and Then
  • Odie Henderson 
    Odie Henderson’s “The Best Man Holiday” Defines ‘Too Long’
  • S. Jhoanna Robledo 
    S. Jhoanna Robledo’s “The Best Man Holiday” Is Short and Smart
  • Sam Adams 
    Sam Adams Consolidates His Thoughts Nicely in “The Best Man Holiday”
  • Josh Bell 
    Josh Bell’s “Disappointing, Belated Sequel” Isn’t Up for Big-Time Analysis
  • Michael Dequina 
    Michael Dequina’s “The Best Man Holiday” Takes Itself Way Too Seriously
  • Mike McCahill 
    Mike McCahill’s Quips Are a Welcome Surprise in “Detached From Reality”
  • John Wirt 
    John Wirt’s “Mixed Blessing” Could Have Mixed in Less Plot
  • Chris Hewitt (St. Paul) 
    Chris Hewitt’s “‘The Best Man Holiday’” Is Honest and Philosophical
  • Bill Gibron 
    Bill Gibron’s “The Best Man Holiday” Sends Out Mixed Messages
  • Mack Bates 
    Take Away the Plot and Not Much Is Left to Mack Bates’s “Engaging Reunion”
  • William Goss 
    William Goss’ “Together Again (Again)” Is a Smooth, Smart Read
  • Kam Williams 
    Less Plot Description Would Have Helped Kam Williams’s “Best Man Holiday”
  • Stephen Farber 
    Stephen Farber’s “The Best Man Holiday” Guides Through Ups and Downs
  • Katey Rich 
    Katey Rich’s “The Best Man Holiday” Relishes Too Much in Spoiler Clues
  • Tara Brady 
    Tara Brady’s “The Best Man Holiday” Is Sharp-Witted Fun
  • Soren Anderson 
    Soren Anderson Keeps Things Light in “The Best Man Holiday”
  • Mike Scott 
    Mike Scott Employs a Clever Metaphor in “‘Best Man Holiday’”
  • Sean O'Connell 
    Avoid the Spoiler First Paragraph of Sean O’Connell’s “Best Man Holiday”
  • Brian Orndorf 
    Brian Orndorf Is All Over the Map in “The Best Man Holiday”
  • Stephanie Zacharek 
    Stephanie Zacharek’s “Part Movie, Part Soap Opera” Is a Breath of Fresh Air
  • Wesley Morris 
    Wesley Morris’s “Best Man Holiday” Loses Its Bite After a Strong Start
  • Susan Granger 
    Susan Granger’s “The Best Man Holiday” Passes the Time With Plot
  • Dann Gire 
    Dann Gire’s “Flawed but Functional Character” Thinks It’s Cute
  • Tim Evans 
    Tim Evans’s “The Best Man Holiday” Lacks Any Real Umph
  • Jon Niccum 
    Jon Niccum’s Funny “‘The Best Man…” Perfectly Shows His Disappointment
  • Frank Swietek 
    Frank Swietek’s Sharp Pen in “The Best Man Holiday” Leaves a Sour Taste
  • Nathan Rabin 
    Nathan Rabin’s “The Best Man Holiday” Is Verbose but Mildly Entertaining
  • Jackie K. Cooper 
    Jackie K. Cooper’s “‘The Best Man Holiday’” Is Warm and Inviting
  • Charlotte O'Sullivan 
    Charlotte O’Sullivan’s “The Best Man Holiday” Sacrifices Substance
  • Willie Waffle 
    Not Too Much Thought Has Gone Into Willie Waffle’s “Yuletide Happiness”
  • Jeffrey M. Anderson 
    Jeffrey M. Anderson Revels in Being a Spoiler in “Festive Friends”
  • Kirk Honeycutt 
    Kirk Honeycutt’s “‘The Best Man Holiday’” Has Personality & Punch
  • Linda Barnard 
    Linda Barnard’s Alright “The Best Man…” Doesn’t Explain 2 Stars
  • Mark Ellis 
    Mark Ellis’s “Best Man Holiday Review” Is Imperfect but Intelligent
  • Wilson Morales 
    Errors Worsen Wilson Morales’s Clunky “The Best Man Holiday”
  • Pete Vonder Haar 
    Pete Vonder Haar’s “The Best Man Holiday” Is Rip-Roaring Fun
  • Chris Bumbray 
    Chris Bumbray Has an Original Take in “The Best Man Holiday”
  • Matt Donato 
    Matt Donato’s “The Best Man Holiday” Lays One Rotten Egg After Another
  • David Noh 
    David Noh Takes Pleasure in Being the Spoiler in “The Best Man Holiday”
  • Randy Cordova 
    Randy Cordova’s List of Nice Things “‘The Best Man…” Doesn’t Convince
  • Tim Brayton 
    Tim Brayton Shows Pointed Personality in “GANG BACK TOGETHER”
  • Elizabeth Weitzman 
    Elizabeth Weitzman’s Vignetting “The Best Man…” Is an Empty Compliment
  • Bilge Ebiri 
    Bilge Ebiri’s “The Best Man Holiday” Is Tasteful & Intelligent
  • Henry Fitzherbert 
    Hebry Fitzherbert’s “The Best Man Holiday” Hardly Seems Worth It
  • Witney Seibold 
    Witney Seibold Is Two-Faced in Contradictory “Yank With a Mighty Furor”
  • Stephen Silver 
    Stephen Silver’s “The Best Man Holiday” Sticks to Its Guns
  • Tom Long 
    Tom Long Has a Sharp Tongue but Blabs in “‘Best’”
  • Drew Taylor 
    Drew Taylor’s “The Book Thief” Is Flawed but Fair