0David Edelstein
3.43David Edelstein Comes Off as a Bully in “Comically Serious” 
| Quality of Writing | Quality of Argument |
| Spoiler Avoidance | Presentation |
Word Count: 715 |
|
4.08David Edelstein’s “Philomena” Is Well Composed
| Quality of Writing | Quality of Argument |
| Spoiler Avoidance | Presentation |
Word Count: 883 |
|
4.53David Edelstein’s “‘Ender’s Game’: “Triumphs With Engaging Presence
| Quality of Writing | Quality of Argument |
| Spoiler Avoidance | Presentation |
Word Count: 535 |
|
3.43David Edelstein’s “Carrie Is Just Uninspired” Has Bite & Some Bark Too
| Quality of Writing | Quality of Argument |
| Spoiler Avoidance | Presentation |
Word Count: 662 |
|
4.23David Edelstein’s “Tom Hanks Is Better Than Ever” Has Passion and Intrigue
| Quality of Writing | Quality of Argument |
| Spoiler Avoidance | Presentation |
Word Count: 738 |
|
3David Edelstein Takes on the Supernatural in “Gravity” Review
| Quality of Writing | Quality of Argument |
| Spoiler Avoidance | Presentation |
Word Count: 917 |
|
2.03David Edelstein’s “Heartbreakingly Good” Requires a Doctorate to Get It
| Quality of Writing | Quality of Argument |
| Spoiler Avoidance | Presentation |
Word Count: 699 |
|
3.18David Edelstein Regards Tone and Mood in “Edelstein on Blue Caprice”
| Quality of Writing | Quality of Argument |
| Spoiler Avoidance | Presentation |
Word Count: 603 |
|
Critic Averages
| Quality of Writing | Quality of Argument |
| Spoiler Avoidance | Presentation |
Average Word Count: |
|
Review Sampler
Optimus
High Reviews-
Justin Chang
4.55
Justin Chang’s Detailed “Desolation of Smaug” Leaves No Stone Unturned -
Manohla Dargis 4.35
Manohla Dargis Will Make You Want to Light Candles With “Gut and Sinew” -
Scott Tobias 4.35
It’s Too Easy to Get Lost in Scott Tobias’ Still Fine “Blue Is…”
