0Ed Gibbs
3.73Ed Gibbs’“Musical Take on a Classic” Covers Only the Basics 
| Quality of Writing | Quality of Argument |
| Spoiler Avoidance | Presentation |
Word Count: 342 |
|
3.03Gibbs’s “Fighting Spirit” Is More Interested in Characters Then Critique
| Quality of Writing | Quality of Argument |
| Spoiler Avoidance | Presentation |
Word Count: 768 |
|
Critic Averages
| Quality of Writing | Quality of Argument |
| Spoiler Avoidance | Presentation |
Average Word Count: |
|
Review Sampler
Optimus
High Reviews-
Adam Lee Davies
4.7
It Doesn’t Get Much Better Than Adam Lee Davies’ “Smaug” -
Sheila O'Malley 4.65
Sheila O’Malley’s “Desolation of Smaug” Brings a Tear of Joy -
Cameron Williams 4.63
Cameron Williams’ “Review—Rush” Fires on All Cylinders to Fine Effect
