0James Berardinelli
3.5James Berardinelli’s “The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug” FlashesGAMEOVER 
| Quality of Writing | Quality of Argument |
| Spoiler Avoidance | Presentation |
Word Count: 832 |
|
3.98James Berardinelli’s “Furnace” Serves Up Delicious Critique
| Quality of Writing | Quality of Argument |
| Spoiler Avoidance | Presentation |
Word Count: 826 |
|
3.83James Berardinelli’s “Llewyn Davis” Baffles More Than It Informs
| Quality of Writing | Quality of Argument |
| Spoiler Avoidance | Presentation |
Word Count: 634 |
|
4.5James Berardinelli’s “Frozen” Takes the Reader on a Pensive Journey
| Quality of Writing | Quality of Argument |
| Spoiler Avoidance | Presentation |
Word Count: 755 |
|
3.93Beware of the Berardinelli Blaze in James Berardinelli’s “Games, The”
| Quality of Writing | Quality of Argument |
| Spoiler Avoidance | Presentation |
Word Count: 1068 |
|
1.88James Berardinelli Protects No Secrets in “Philomena”
| Quality of Writing | Quality of Argument |
| Spoiler Avoidance | Presentation |
Word Count: 679 |
|
4.33James Berardinelli Refuses to Be Manipulated in “The Best Man Holiday”
| Quality of Writing | Quality of Argument |
| Spoiler Avoidance | Presentation |
Word Count: 837 |
|
3.83James Berardinelli Explores the Depths of Criticism in “Nebraska”
| Quality of Writing | Quality of Argument |
| Spoiler Avoidance | Presentation |
Word Count: 849 |
|
3.63James Berardinelli’s Cutting Wit Hits Home in “Book Thief, The”
| Quality of Writing | Quality of Argument |
| Spoiler Avoidance | Presentation |
Word Count: 825 |
|
3.73James Berardinelli’s Review of “Ender’s Game” Recovers After a Slow Start
| Quality of Writing | Quality of Argument |
| Spoiler Avoidance | Presentation |
Word Count: 948 |
|
1.65James Berardinelli’s Clinical Approach to “Dallas Buyers Club” Is Bland
| Quality of Writing | Quality of Argument |
| Spoiler Avoidance | Presentation |
Word Count: 788 |
|
3.23James Berardinelli’s “Counselor, The” Rambles, but Scores Points
| Quality of Writing | Quality of Argument |
| Spoiler Avoidance | Presentation |
Word Count: 737 |
|
3.18James Berardinelli’s Impassioned Pop-Up Prone “Blue Is The…” Succeeds
| Quality of Writing | Quality of Argument |
| Spoiler Avoidance | Presentation |
Word Count: 982 |
|
2.58James Berardinelli’s “Escape Plan” Is a Dismissive, Halfhearted Affair
| Quality of Writing | Quality of Argument |
| Spoiler Avoidance | Presentation |
Word Count: 840 |
|
4.65James Berardinelli’s Top-Notch “Carrie” Leads to a Satisfying Conclusion
| Quality of Writing | Quality of Argument |
| Spoiler Avoidance | Presentation |
Word Count: 835 |
|
4.85James Berardinelli’s Compelling “12 Years” Hits All the Right Notes
| Quality of Writing | Quality of Argument |
| Spoiler Avoidance | Presentation |
Word Count: 805 |
|
2.63James Berardinelli, “Romeo + Juliet (2013)” Tries Hard but Misses the Point
| Quality of Writing | Quality of Argument |
| Spoiler Avoidance | Presentation |
Word Count: 752 |
|
3.85James Berardinelli’s Solid “Captain Phillips” Takes Some Strange Turns
| Quality of Writing | Quality of Argument |
| Spoiler Avoidance | Presentation |
Word Count: 720 |
|
2.18James Berardinelli’s “‘Gravity’” Is Ill-Pitched and Exhausting
| Quality of Writing | Quality of Argument |
| Spoiler Avoidance | Presentation |
Word Count: 978 |
|
2.55James Berardinelli’s “Runner Runner Review” Is Sleep-Inducing
| Quality of Writing | Quality of Argument |
| Spoiler Avoidance | Presentation |
Word Count: 686 |
|
2.18James Berardinelli’s “Rush” Is Slow to the Point and Dull
| Quality of Writing | Quality of Argument |
| Spoiler Avoidance | Presentation |
Word Count: 852 |
|
2.88James Berardinelli’s “Don Jon Review” Is Too Bland and Gives Too Much Away
| Quality of Writing | Quality of Argument |
| Spoiler Avoidance | Presentation |
Word Count: 881 |
|
4.38James Berardinelli Is a Master Who Takes His Time in “Prisoners”
| Quality of Writing | Quality of Argument |
| Spoiler Avoidance | Presentation |
Word Count: 953 |
|
2.48Berardinelli’s “‘Enough Said’ Review” Is One Long Complaint
| Quality of Writing | Quality of Argument |
| Spoiler Avoidance | Presentation |
Word Count: 581 |
|
1.3James Berardinelli’s “World’s End, The” Is a Meandering Mess
| Quality of Writing | Quality of Argument |
| Spoiler Avoidance | Presentation |
Word Count: 941 |
|
2.5James Berardinelli’s “Kick-Ass 2” Is Not a Game Changer
| Quality of Writing | Quality of Argument |
| Spoiler Avoidance | Presentation |
Word Count: 1000 |
|
Critic Averages
| Quality of Writing | Quality of Argument |
| Spoiler Avoidance | Presentation |
Average Word Count: |
|
Review Sampler
Optimus
High Reviews-
Adam Fendelman
4.75
Adam Fendelman’s “Almost Passable” Is Devilish Fun -
Genevieve Koski 4.68
Genevieve Koski’s “Catching Fire” Defines Criticism -
John Serba 4.28
John Serba’s “Catching Fire” Blazes, but Is Only Serba-Esque
